Time-restricted eating is heavily promoted in the online health sphere and for good reason: It offers potential benefits that go beyond the diet.
1
What Is A Feeding Window?
When we intentionally eat at specific times and avoid eating the rest of the time, this is called time-restricted eating.
Eat only when the “window” is open.
Example: The window is open from 9 AM to 5 PM.
Fast (don’t eat) outside the window.
Example: Stop eating after 5 pm –> until the next morning at 9 am.
There Are Many Variations
There are all sorts of odd methods, (such as “one meal per day” or “36 hour fast/12 hour binge”). The more extreme the approach, the larger the amount of risk.
However, the most popular approach is an 8-hour feeding window. All calories for the day are eaten between 9am and 5pm.
Intermittent fasting is eating within a window of time — and fasting the rest of the day.
Intermittent fasting is also known as
“time-restricted eating.”
2
The Benefits Of Time-Restricted Eating
There are some interesting effects when eating this way (TRE).
Questions To Ask
- Are these benefits available to everyone?
- Are these benefits sustainable in the long-run?
- Is time-restricted eating the only way to achieve these benefits?
You can lose weight.
It can be convenient.
Temporarily benefit gut health.
It can increase autophagy.
You can avoid circadian mistakes.
Possibly improved NADH to NAD+ ratio.
3
What The Science Says
Perhaps surprisingly, the research about intermittent fasting is scant.
There simply aren’t many studies performed on the subject of time-restricted eating. Given how much internet attention this approach is enjoying, it’s amazing how little science is out there to back it up.
However, there is a 2018 study that demonstrated that time-restricted eating improved the following markers in pre-diabetic men, even though none of them lost weight:
- insulin sensitivity
- blood pressure
- oxidative stress
- appetite
The 6-hour feeding window these men followed was 8am to 2pm.
Therefore, the suggested benefits of time-restricted feeding are largely theoretical.
3
Many Options
There are many ways to implement a feeding window. Here are examples of different popular approaches.
2-Hour
Feeding Window
This is essentially “one meal a day” (OMAD).
Typically, one massive mid-afternoon meal.
4-Hour
Feeding Window
Typically, four hours of intense grazing — or, one long meal.
8-Hour
Feeding Window
Highly popular, though somewhat extreme for many.
Two meals per day is the most common method, here.
Two popular Options
12-Hour
Feeding Window
A more sustainable option.
Three meals per day works, here.
5
Who Benefits?
Some folks might benefit from experimenting with time-restricted eating.
Those who could benefit most from intermittent fasting are those struggling with:
6
The Risks
The challenges of intermittent fasting are not often mentioned, but they can be significant.
Chronic Undereating
When restricting feeding to a shortened window, it can become difficult to consume enough calories for an entire day.
Over time, undereating can be a serious offender to health. Chronic caloric malnourishment can directly:
- harm thyroid function
- weaken immunity
- cause nutrient deficiency
- interfere with sleep
- wreck hormone production
In time-restricted eating, it’s imperative that basic caloric requirements be met, long-term. This means it’s a must to meet daily caloric requirements — and that can be a challenge with this approach.
Appetite Suppression
A healthy appetite is a marker of healthy metabolism, balanced hormones, and robust gut health.
Unfortunately, the appetite has been shown to be reduced in time-restricted eating.
This is often celebrated as a benefit, but it can be a danger, too.
This phenomenon is common throughout the health world, where there are many undernourished dieters — following all sorts of restrictive dietary plans — who notice a diminished appetite.
A poor appetite can be a real problem for health, and a signal that the body is shutting down and going into “starvation mode.”
In response to fewer calories, the metabolism is likely to slow, adapting to the lack of fuel — even while the dieter often joyfully raves about his/her lack of appetite and cravings.
This can certainly be playing with fire, and a major reason I do not recommend most time-restricted diets.
Worse still, it’s possible for people to have serious gut health problems that are being indirectly addressed by eating less or fasting — but is undernourishment and a slower metabolism the only answer?
Another problem: In this study, subjects were only followed for 5 weeks — a very short time to fully understand the long-term implications of any dietary practice.
Poor Sleep
Undernourishment can be disastrous for sleep in the long run.
Eating too late in the day is also bad for sleep, and can also slow the metabolism and confuse the circadian rhythm.
On the other hand, eating too early — and closing the feeding window too early in the evening can cause insomnia as well. For many people, even a supper as early as 5pm can cause sleep to suffer. A chronic caloric deficit will only exacerbate this issue.
Added Stress
While some enjoy having simplified daily structure and clear rules to follow, for others strict rules can add unnecessary stress.
Therefore, intermittent fasting may work for some while not working for others.
If you’re not motivated by strict rule-following, there may be better ways to improve your insulin sensitivity and induce autophagy.
No Proper Meal Times
Intermittent fasting often results in the disappearance of true meals. Instead, it’s common to eat as much as possible while the feeding window is open.
Some folks try to keep a focus on meals — by eating two meals per day. This can be a real challenge for many, though, and it often results in lots of grazing and snacking.
However, grazing and snacking is problematic for the body for several reasons: It’s quite bad for gut health and it ignores circadian rhythms that control the digestive, endocrine, and adrenal systems.
For longer feeding windows (such as a 12-hour feeding window), there’s certainly no need to “graze all day.” It’s best to eat designated meals whenever possible.
Undereating Now –> Causes Overfeeding Later
Rebound overeating can be a real problem with intermittent fasting.
In fact, advocates of TRE/IF claim that many benefits are due to lower caloric intake.
Unfortunately, eating less than the body needs is not a long-term strategy.
Chronic undereating will always result in a rebound. Will-power can only withstand the body’s needs for so long — and it shouldn’t try to because it overutilizes stress hormones.
Days or even weeks of rebound overeating may be required to regain energy lost to dieting. This will be most true for those of us with compromised health — we cannot afford to undereat for very long.
With any diet that fails to supply adequate calories and nutrition, two things are guaranteed to happen:
- A diet rebound (where weight lost is quickly regained)
- A slowing of the metabolism
Now, all of this can be avoided by simply meeting daily caloric requirements. Again, that’s very difficult to do for many people in this diet.
Skipping… Breakfast
It’s popular to skip breakfast when following an 8-hour window.
This usually results in a 12-8 feeding time, with meals eaten at lunch & dinner. The result is often lots of afternoon-snacking, too, to make up for inadequate caloric intake, or pushing the window later in the evening.
While the potential problems with skipping breakfast aren’t a terrible threat for most average people who only need to control caloric intake, it is still quite far from optimal.
The main issue: Research suggests that eating earlier in the day is better for all sorts of health metrics: weight, circadian rhythm, gut health, inflammation, hormone balance, and more.
8
The Best Option
The best meal timing is time tested. It’s even, perhaps, boring.
But it works — in all sorts of situations, goals, and health challenges.
Meal times are all but disappearing in modern society. In fact, only 27% of people eat three square meals per day.
Instead, 3/4 of Americans are eschewing meals and snacking whenever they can find a minute in their day.
What’s more? New research is showing the benefits of time-restricted eating can even be found with a large eating window of 16-hours. That’s hardly a feeding window at all.
Perhaps intermittent fasting is developing to combat the erosion of our meal times — to prevent us from snacking all day without any structure.
Three Meals Per Day
Our grandparents’ generation knew what they were doing — at least when it comes to meal timing.
This generation ate at times that supported every single biological function. They at early. They ate often. They stopped eating pretty early.
Back then, a typical daily meal schedule might look like this:
A traditional “three meals” is essentially a 12-hour feeding window.
Eat Dinner As Early As You Like
The best feature of eating three square meals: Folks without blood sugar instability can nudge dinner earlier to lengthen the overnight fast.
Earlier dinners will create a longer fasting window overnight while sustainably supporting high-energy performance throughout the day.
An earlier dinner means finishing dinner around 6 pm (in most locales).
9
A Solid Approach
Benefits Of “Three Meals” Per Day
Eat Early
Take advantage of the metabolism-boosting effects of a solid, early breakfast.
Eat Often
Support the metabolism by skipping the extremely long fasting periods.
Eat Enough
You aren’t trying to squeeze an entire day’s food into a small window, just so you don’t fall short on calories.
It’s Sustainable
This way is likely to serve you well indefinitely. No gimmicks, it just works.
Eating shortly after waking up each morning is best for your metabolism and your circadian rhythm.
Finishing dinner by 7 pm is perfect for sleep.
- You’ll have plenty of time for digestion to begin before bedtime.
No approach adequately solves as many problems as “three meals a day.”
10
Experiment!
The spirit of experimentation is almost always a good thing.
Especially for those who “need something different,” feeding windows can be a great way to change things up.
Feeding windows can counter the constant snacking that’s dominating modern society.
What’s the main risk with diet experimentation?
Some dietary theories teach dangerous theories and bad habits. Some instill fear of entire food groups. Eating disorders among health-seekers are all-to-common in the growing internet health sphere.
Don’t keep bad theories and bad habits after the experiment is over. If something isn’t truly serving you — and producing results — leave it behind.
Finally, over the long run, don’t forget that eating “three meals a day” — at proper times — is potentially the most optimal approach, because it:
Read more:
Articles
Max: “It’s so clear how much thought you’ve put into the site.”
“You have changed how I think about what I expect from every health professional I work with. You are a rockstar!
You are practical, not selling an agenda and so open-minded, which comes through in your writing. It’s so clear how much thought you’ve put into the site, and the content and delivery of content is unparalleled.
You are thorough, but also able to communicate in a way that’s not overwhelming, which I feel is a really hard to balance. You’re able to communicate this stuff 100x better than anyone else out there.
I’m often referencing your site in my mind as I’ve been helping my brother work through issues.
I’m so appreciative of you and your work — the mindset you’ve given me is invaluable. You’ve trained and taught me well!”
Max Friedman
Massachussetts, USA
Josh: “The material on this website is extremely clear cut.”
“I just want to say: Travis Burch has been key to my healing process over the last year, which is getting better and better.
Coming from so many different dietary influences, I feel as though Travis has shown me the balance that I needed.
If I could have gone back in time 4 years ago, when I started searching into health, and had access to the knowledge on this website and Travis’ direct support I would have sorted a lot of issues I had out a long time ago and saved my self a lot of tim.
The material on this website is extremely clear cut, organised and actually very enjoyable and easy to read. Never have I been so interested and excited when looking into health. Everything is actionable and there are a million things I’ve taken from the website to improve so many issues I had (sleep improved greatly, circadian rhythm, energy levels, skin issues have improved, strength in the gym are just a few of many others, oh and also balance, so key). Everything you need to heal is here on this website.
Also working with Travis directly he has been able to troubleshoot a lot of issues and I am always so grateful for the time he takes to help me. He really does put thought and effort into every single response I have from him and honestly just cannot thank him enough.”
Josh Clement
United Kingdom
Luna: “I wanted to keep Travis a secret out of fear that his prices would go up a thousand fold, because he is worth that much.”
“I have been searching the internet for years trying to find solutions for the various health conditions my family and I have been suffering from. Because of that, I would go into various rabbit holes of I formation which would promise ultimate healing by following certain diets and or protocols. I had information and books about GAPS, the Specific Carbohydrate Diet, Paleo, Keto, Medical Medium, Jack Kruse, Ray Peat, prometabolic eating so on.
Every time I would find some new information — or some kind of answers — I would get excited, and I would try to apply the information! But I would also try to make sense of it in the context of all of the other information that I had gathered from the past
One day, while searching through message boards and forums, Travis’s website popped up. The guy seemed to have a handle on all of the information. I was highly impressed and decided to book a free call so I could basically spew all of the information that I had read for the past two years onto him.
From the beginning I was so moved by his kindness and vast knowledge. He was not only familiar with all of the things that I asked him, he was able to explain how that information fit into my particular situation. I had tried to reach out to various people in the past and they all demanded money for the slightest interaction or were incredibly pompous and rude to be asked even a simple question. I had SO many questions to ask him before deciding whether to work with him. I wanted to make sure that he know at least as much as I did about all the things. He was so patient and answered all of my questions without ever sounding annoyed or in a rush to “get” me as a paying client.
More than the actual knowledge that he has (which is vast) about various health theories and perspectives, it was his presence that was most healing. Just having someone whom I could bounce ideas off of and who would knew where I was coming from was so reassuring. I felt like I was literally juggling the whole internet’s worth of information by myself with no way to figure out which way to go or what to take as truth and what to discard and his amazing amount of understanding really helped me traverse it all.
Travis helped me to feel that I wasn’t completely alone trying to heal me and my family’s health. And that feeling was the most healing of all. I am hoping to start working with him again soon. In the meantime he is always willing to answer random questions that pop into my mind.
I wanted to keep Travis a secret out of fear that his prices would go up a thousand fold, because he is worth that much. But I know what it’s like to suffer alone trying to find answers in an endless sea of information. I believe that he can help many people. Thank you Travis! You have really been a God-send.”
Luna Tomy
USA
Jaemin — “Travis has given me my life back.”
“I’ve been on an 8-year long journey of struggling with hypothyroidism and a ton of health issues stemming from that (i.e. chronic fatigue, depression, weak immune system, insomnia, constant sore throats, digestive issues, etc.) I’ve seen tons of different doctors, naturopaths, healers (and spent thousands of dollars) with little to no results.
In the first few months of working with Travis, my issues started to reverse almost instantly! Within 6-12 months, I felt like I had healed 80-90% of my issues. It was remarkable. And with so much day-to-day support. He’s also very open-minded and non-dogmatic, so he’ll work with you however you want to explore things. Not to mention, he’s also just an incredibly caring and awesome human being. Navigating my health journey has been infinitely more manageable and less overwhelming with Travis by my side.
Travis has given me my life back and I can’t thank him enough for it! And his ideas and perspectives on health feel absolutely foundational to me. Your mileage will vary with any health coach or protocol, as everybody and situation is different, but I’m convinced that Travis’ coaching would be helpful to pretty much everybody. His protocols feel absolutely fundamental to me for better health.”
Jaemin Yi
California, USA
Diane — “I can personally attest that Travis Burch is the real deal.”
“There are seemingly endless numbers of health and nutrition gurus selling protocols, but very very few of them actually possess the qualities needed to heal for a person struggling from ill health or disease.
I can personally attest that Travis Burch is the real deal. I’m forever grateful to have crossed paths with him at a very crucial time during which the collective health of my family had fallen apart as a result of living in a moldy house.
His in-depth understanding of nutrition, lifestyle (and their interactions) and the way in which the environment influences our health (good and bad) is astounding.
But, the best part is that he’s big-hearted and has a faculty for tuning in and listening that effectively sets him apart from others in the field. Thank you, Travis!”
Diane Tantimonaco
California, USA
Shea — “I’m constantly reading and referring to this.”
Thank you so much! Love the content, I’m constantly reading and referring to it! Now I’ve got it for life! ❤️
Shea Frith
Australia
S.M. — “Saved me a lot of money.”
“I have suffered from chronic digestive issues for decades. I tried so many things and was feeling so lost, just getting worse, never better. Never knew what I should be eating-my health was getting worse and it was taking a toll on my work, my relationships. Working with Travis over the past year has helped me tremendously. He understands what it feels like to feel anxious and confused and so sick of being sick. He is a helping hand in a sea of confusing health information. He has such a level head and takes a reasonable approach to healing (starting with foundations). He really listens. He sends quick, thoughtful replies everytime I write him. He has been there for me when I was really scared or unsure how to proceed. I always feel better after our zooms. He is patient and answers all my questions and never makes me feel dumb no matter how many questions I have. He has saved me a lot of money with his many hacks and product recommendations! If you hire Travis as your health coach he will help you heal, and this may not be overnight, it takes time to undo years of being sick, but he will be there and stick with you as you figure things out, and teach you a lot!”
SM, R.D.
Massachussetts, USA
Viveka: “This is the most practical and helpful source…”
“Informed by Travis’ extensive personal experience, this is the most practical and helpful source of info on grounding, light, and electromagnetic healing I’ve seen on the web.”
Viveka Jagadeesan
USA
Bart: “Travis has helped me tremendously…”
“With his website and coaching Travis gives a very clear picture about what constitutes health, which he describes perfectly through his pillars of health. As a coach he is highly engaged and responds quickly to all your questions. He has helped me tremendously in dealing with illness and navigating the maze of online self help recommendations and I can’t thank him enough.”
Bart Lutmers
Netherlands
Mandy: “Extremely patient and really listens.”
“Travis Burch is extremely patient and really listens.
He has helped me recently discover some major issues with my regimen and I’m forever grateful!”
Mandy Rode
Alberta, Canada
Brooke: “There’s no agenda or bias — only what works.”
“Without Travis my health wouldn’t be where it is today. The Pillars of health show EVERYTHING you need to know about health.
I honestly can’t put into words how helpful they have been to me. They flipped everything for me — it was the balance I needed in my life.
I find myself going back to this pretty often when needed now! Oh, would it have saved me time having access to this years ago!
Travis himself is different from anyone I’ve spoken to in the health world, I’m constantly blown away every time I speak with him. He will look at every angle of my questions and always give me the light at the end of the tunnel with my problems (Even my more silly questions!)
Travis you are a kind, amazing person: you listen, you are patient, & you want to help. Your understanding of health is essentially on a different planet. From every moving part, you’ve let me explore my issues in my own time and way, with no pressure that might make me feel overwhelmed. You put enormous amounts of effort into every single thing you do. I’m forever grateful for the help you have given me over the years.
There’s no agenda or bias with Travis, only what works, he is the real deal.”
Brooke Collins
U.K.
Krystie: “Thank you for this wonderful gift!”
“I’ve been happy to support your site as your information is extremely comprehensive, and you can see how much effort you’ve put into your research to help others heal.
Thank you for this wonderful gift!“
Krystie Kyes
USA
Erica: “A life-changing practitioner to work with. “
“I’ve been working with Travis for over a year. I can’t over-emphasize the influence he has had on my life, on my health, and my happiness. I started working with Travis just as I came down with a chronic health condition called gastroparesis (“GP”). I was convinced by the medical community, scientific literature, and the general consensus of anyone who has this condition that I would have it for life, and at the very best be able to manage my symptoms with medication and drastic, permanent dietary changes.
Over the past year, Travis helped me recover from an all time low with my health. Working with Travis gave me the gift of no longer believing I’ll suffer from a chronic health condition the rest of my life. It allowed me to be able to eat foods I wasn’t sure I could safely eat again, be able to feel energy I wasn’t sure would return, be able to have substantial periods of time where I’m healthy & feeling great and to experience my health continuously (but not linearly) improving.
I can’t recommend working with him enough. Travis is so methodical, thorough, practical, and an incredible person – which makes him a life-changing practitioner to work with. Thank you for everything Travis, endless appreciation for all that you do!“
Erica Mulford
USA
(click to return to home page)
